When I'm trying new barbecue, I always try to find that good thing to say. But sometimes, the best I can do is say, 'Well, they've got good rolls' or 'They got good ice tea.' Anyone in the know will understand what that means.
This place is 3 blocks from my old house and 10 from my new one. Went there today. Sausage was superb. Brisket above average. Ribs average - probably because he re-warms them (see comment in story). I actually had a conversation with the owner several months back while he was renovating. Definitely the kind of old school guy we like. I will just have to ignore [censored by editor] his offspring (again, see story).
Ribs - fully rendered almost fall off the bone tenderness with a good balanced rub and marinade. These ribs are done to perfection but for my liking could use a bit more rub.
Pulled pork - nicely balanced between meat and sauce. Very nice!
Brisket - basically served like chopped beef covered in a light sauce. Nicely smoked and good flavor but I prefer my brisket stand up/sliced.
Spare Rib - Best texture so far. Good exterior texture, and the meat inside is fully rendered. Not oily or juicy, but moist and good. Delicious!
Brisket - Although it is chopped and lightly sauced, the flavor of the beef comes shining through. Actually, the application is more like a "dip" than a sauce, and just moistens and enhances the meat.
Spare Rib - Good. Chunky bits come off together. These are big ribs, and are not fully rendered on the meaty ends.
Brisket - Nice thick slices. Good spice in the rub. Meat is tender any juicy, although a little "pot-roasty" due to being held warm. Best sliced brisket we have found in Richmond.
Pulled Pork - North Carolina style. Served with a generous amount of dip. The meat seems to need the dip, as I find some pieces seem a bit dry (even when wet).
Brisket - nice thick cut, good accordion style and very tender. Best VA brisket around. Could be star anise in the rub and/or marinade adds nice flavor.
Pulled Pork - true eastern NC style with lots of vinegar and red pepper.
Ribs - tough meat with fat not fully rendered. Good spicey rub.
Other Fare:
Potato Salad - standard fare
Cole Slaw - nasty thick cut mush
Baked Beans - better taste then it looks but nothing special